TikTok, the short-form video platform, has become one of the most influential forces in global culture, boasting over a billion active users worldwide. While it provides an engaging space for entertainment and connection, its growing dominance is raising concerns about its impact on the creative industry. In this article, I argue that TikTok, despite its allure, is inadvertently stifling creativity, devaluing art, and reshaping the creative economy in detrimental ways.
1. The Rise of Instant Gratification Culture
TikTok thrives on brevity, with most videos lasting less than 60 seconds. This format caters to a culture of instant gratification, where viewers expect immediate engagement without the patience for deeper storytelling or artistry.
Traditional creative mediums—whether films, novels, or even intricate art pieces—demand time, effort, and a willingness to immerse oneself in the creator’s vision. On TikTok, however, creativity is often compressed into a fleeting moment designed to grab attention rather than evoke reflection. This prioritization of surface-level entertainment risks devaluing the rich, layered narratives that have historically defined the creative arts.
2. Algorithm-Driven Homogenization
TikTok’s algorithm rewards content that adheres to trends. The "For You" page—the app's heart—prioritizes popular sounds, challenges, and formats, encouraging creators to jump on existing bandwagons rather than innovate.
While trends can be fun and engaging, they often lead to a homogenized creative landscape. Creators who want visibility feel compelled to conform, replicating similar dances, lip-syncs, or meme templates. This stifles originality, as the pressure to chase virality overshadows the pursuit of unique artistic expression. The result? A creative ecosystem where the loudest trends drown out the quieter voices of originality.
3. Erosion of Artistic Depth
Creating meaningful art often involves research, practice, and a deep understanding of the subject. TikTok’s emphasis on rapid, easily digestible content discourages this depth.
For example, musicians may feel pressured to write 15-second hooks that work well on TikTok rather than creating entire songs that tell a story. Visual artists may create “satisfying” art for the algorithm rather than work on complex pieces that require time and contemplation. In this environment, artistic depth gives way to superficiality, reducing art to its most marketable components.
4. Monetization Challenges for True Artists
While TikTok has provided a platform for creators worldwide, including Kenyans, to showcase their talent and gain visibility, it often falls short in translating this visibility into sustainable income. The monetization model it employs—relying on creator funds, brand partnerships, and live-stream gifts—is skewed towards rewarding quantity over quality, leaving many Kenyan artists grappling with financial instability despite their popularity on the platform.
Rewarding Quantity Over Quality
In Kenya, where traditional art forms such as music, poetry, filmmaking, and painting are deeply rooted in culture, TikTok’s emphasis on rapid, consistent content production often puts true artists at a disadvantage. For example, a Kenyan filmmaker or visual artist might spend weeks or even months working on a high-quality project that tells a compelling story or showcases intricate craftsmanship. However, on TikTok, such depth is overshadowed by creators who churn out lighthearted, trend-driven videos daily.
This pressure to produce frequent, short-form content can lead Kenyan artists to prioritize the "trending" over the timeless. A musician might create catchy, 15-second snippets for TikTok instead of crafting a complete album, or a spoken word poet might reduce their work to a few punchy lines that fit within the platform’s format, sacrificing the depth and nuance that traditional audiences value.
Brand Partnerships Favor Social Stars, Not Artists
In Kenya, most creators on TikTok who manage to secure brand partnerships are lifestyle influencers, dancers, or comedians whose content aligns with mainstream consumer interests. For traditional artists like sculptors, filmmakers, or visual storytellers, it can be challenging to attract brands that are more interested in broad, instant appeal rather than niche, culturally significant artistry.
For instance, Kenyan fashion designers who highlight cultural heritage in their work may not find sponsors willing to fund their art unless they tailor it to TikTok-friendly formats like dances or dramatic reveals. This sidelining of traditional artistry reinforces a system where only the most "marketable" creators, not necessarily the most talented or innovative, are rewarded.
The Burden of Algorithmic Relevance
TikTok’s algorithm also exacerbates the problem. Kenyan creators must navigate the app’s opaque algorithm, which rewards engagement metrics such as likes, shares, and comments. This system creates a constant race for visibility, where an artist's content must not only be good but also frequent and trendy.
For instance, a filmmaker in Nairobi might have a creative short film that struggles to gain traction because it doesn’t align with the current TikTok trend, while a dance challenge using a popular song garners millions of views. This forces creators to compromise their artistic integrity just to remain visible, eroding the value of their work over time.
Limited Opportunities for Traditional Artists
Kenya has a rich history of artistic expression, from Maasai beadwork and storytelling to contemporary urban graffiti. However, these art forms are not easily monetizable on TikTok. For example, an artist in Kisumu or Mombasa might specialize in creating intricate, handcrafted items that cannot be captured in 15-second videos. The platform's emphasis on digital entertainment over physical, tangible art leaves such creators without a viable avenue to promote or earn from their work.
Additionally, Kenyan filmmakers and musicians who rely on long-term projects often face significant challenges in funding and distributing their work. TikTok's model does little to alleviate these struggles, as it promotes quick consumption rather than the thoughtful engagement that these creators seek.
Inconsistent Revenue Streams
For many Kenyan creators, the revenue streams TikTok offers are inconsistent and unreliable. Live-stream gifts, for instance, require a creator to have a dedicated audience willing to donate regularly. Given Kenya’s socioeconomic realities, where disposable income for online tipping is limited, even talented creators may find it difficult to sustain themselves financially through TikTok alone.
Moreover, the Creator Fund, available in select countries, is not yet accessible to Kenyan creators. This exclusion forces them to rely solely on brand collaborations or off-platform monetization strategies, further widening the gap between visibility and income.
5. The Commodification of Creativity
TikTok has contributed to the commodification of creativity, where artistic expression becomes less about personal vision and more about consumer appeal.
The platform’s emphasis on metrics like likes, views, and shares turns creativity into a numbers game. Success is measured not by the quality or impact of a piece but by its ability to go viral. This shift risks alienating creators who value substance over spectacle, pushing them to either conform to TikTok’s demands or risk obscurity.
6. Plagiarism and Lack of Credit
One of TikTok’s darkest undercurrents is its rampant culture of plagiarism. Original ideas, dances, or concepts are frequently copied and re-uploaded by others without proper credit to the original creator.
For instance, the viral "Renegade" dance popularized on TikTok was initially created by Jalaiah Harmon, a young Black dancer who received little recognition initially. Such cases highlight how TikTok’s ecosystem often rewards those who mimic or exploit creativity rather than innovate. This culture of appropriation can demoralize original creators, further undermining the industry’s integrity.
The relentless pressure to stay relevant on TikTok takes a toll on creators’ mental health. The constant need to produce viral content fosters a toxic environment of comparison, burnout, and self-doubt.
Moreover, the platform’s unpredictable algorithm can leave creators feeling powerless. A video that took hours to produce might flop, while a hastily made clip goes viral. This unpredictability exacerbates anxiety and discourages creators from investing deeply in their craft.
7. The Illusion of Accessibility
TikTok markets itself as a platform that democratizes creativity, giving anyone the tools to create and share. While this is true to some extent, it overlooks the inherent inequalities in the system.
Creators with access to better equipment, editing software, or financial resources are at an advantage. Additionally, TikTok’s algorithm often favors content from established creators or those who can afford to promote their posts, marginalizing emerging voices. The result is a platform that mirrors existing inequities rather than leveling the playing field.
Conclusion
TikTok’s meteoric rise has undoubtedly reshaped the creative landscape, offering new opportunities for visibility and connection. However, its emphasis on instant gratification, algorithm-driven trends, and commodification poses significant challenges to the creative industry.
As creators and consumers, we must critically examine TikTok’s influence and advocate for spaces that prioritize depth, originality, and sustainability. The creative industry thrives on diversity, experimentation, and the freedom to take risks—values that TikTok’s current model often undermines. By recognizing these challenges, we can work towards a more balanced ecosystem that nurtures, rather than stifles, creativity.
Comments
Edit Comment
×